In today’s fast-paced digital world, texting has become second nature. But few realize how a single message can become pivotal in a legal case. Whether you're involved in a criminal investigation or facing legal scrutiny, understanding how your text messages may be used in court is crucial. At The Law Offices of Dominic Paul Candino, based in Buffalo, New York, we help clients navigate the complexities of modern digital communication in criminal defense.

 

If you have concerns about text message evidence, don't wait— contact us today or call 716-674-8900 to speak with an experienced criminal defense attorney in Buffalo.

Can Text Messages Be Used as Evidence?

Yes— text messages are admissible in criminal court, but not automatically. They must meet strict criteria:

• Authenticity: The prosecution must link a message to a specific device or user.

• Relevance: Messages must pertain directly to the case.

• Compliance: They must follow evidentiary rules laid out by New York and federal courts.

In short, while a text may seem minor, it can carry serious legal weight.

What About Deleted Texts?

Many believe deleting a message makes it disappear—but that’s a myth. Law enforcement agencies can often recover deleted messages from mobile devices, especially if they act quickly. If you’ve been involved in an incident and attempt to delete messages afterward, it could be seen as tampering with evidence —a serious criminal offense.

If you're facing investigation or charges in Western New York, consult an attorney before taking any action. At our firm, we’ve helped clients throughout Buffalo protect their rights in sensitive situations.

Are Screenshots Enough?

While screenshots of text messages can support your defense, they come with challenges. Screenshots are easily manipulated and lack the full metadata needed to verify their authenticity. Courts generally prefer original messages stored on the device or extracted by forensic experts. A single screenshot might not show the full conversation or context—making it unreliable on its own.

Are My Texts Really Private?

Not entirely. Even if you believe a conversation is private, your messages can still be obtained through:

• Search warrants

• Phone provider records

• Another person’s device

If you live in Buffalo or the surrounding area and are concerned about whether your texts could be used against you, it’s critical to seek legal guidance. The Law Offices of Dominic Paul Candino is ready to help you understand your rights.

Innocent Messages Can Be Misinterpreted

Something said in jest—like sarcasm or a vague joke—might be interpreted differently in court. Without tone or context, innocent messages can appear incriminating. For example, a joke about “getting away with something” might be misconstrued as intent, especially when isolated from the rest of the conversation.

We urge clients across Erie County to think twice before sending texts that could be misunderstood.

Challenging Text Message Evidence

Fortunately, text messages can be challenged in court. Some common defense strategies include:

• Questioning the chain of custody

• Providing context for misleading statements

• Disputing authorship or access to the device

Attorney Dominic Paul Candino brings over 30 years of courtroom experience and a deep understanding of how to challenge digital evidence effectively in New York State courts.

How to Protect Yourself

Here are a few precautions you can take to avoid legal trouble related to text messages:

• Avoid sending sensitive or emotional texts.

• Don’t delete messages after a potential legal incident.

• Keep your phone locked and secure.

And most importantly, if you're worried that something you've texted could come back to haunt you, speak with a qualified defense attorney in Buffalo, NY as soon as possible.

Get the Legal Guidance You Need

 

Digital evidence, especially text messages, plays a growing role in criminal proceedings. The best way to protect yourself is through knowledge and experienced legal representation. At The Law Offices of Dominic Paul Candino, we provide trusted legal counsel to clients across Buffalo and the greater Western New York area.

If you’re facing criminal charges or are under investigation, don’t face it alone. Contact our office or call 716-674-8900 for a confidential consultation.